Walthamstow: Anti-EDL campaigners defy march ban

on Sunday, October 28, 2012

Campaigners against the far-right English Defence League (EDL) defied a protest ban by marching through Walthamstow after scuffles with police this afternoon.

Officers struggled to contain a crowd of several hundred who broke away from a legal static protest outside the former EMD cinema in Hoe Street at around 1.30pm. Protesters pushed through a cordon and marched several hundred metres down to the junction with Selborne Road, where police reinforcements eventually stopped them.

The static protest began at 11am and was organised by umbrella group We Are Waltham Forest (WAWF) and Unite Against Fascism (UAF) to celebrate their "defeat" of the EDL in the borough.

The EDL, which claims to be a movement opposed to Islamic extremism but which critics say is racist, had wanted to march through Walthamstow today (Saturday October 27). But earlier this week the government issued a ban on all marches in the borough for 30 days following police intelligence there could be violence and disruption. The Met also imposed special "conditions" on the EDL which meant its supporters could only hold a static demonstration outside the Houses of Parliament.

The Guardian witnessed two youths being led from the town centre by police at 10.30am but there was otherwise no visible presence of any possible EDL supporters in Walthamstow.

Estimates over the number of people who attended the static anti-EDL rally vary from 200 to 1,000. A series of figures, including union representatives and WAWF campaigners, held speeches from a lorry before the crowd was told to "walk orderly" back to Walthamstow Central by organisers just after 1pm.

But defiant sections of the crowd chanted "let us march" and pushed past police who were outnumbered. The Guardian did not witness anyone being arrested or injured. Some protesters and police officers pushed each other but this newspaper did not see any serious violence.

Meanwhile a council-organised funday on the adjacent Arcade Site and town square designed to celebrate the borough's diversity was largely unaffected by the protest. Fairground rides on the Arcade Site did not open at 11am as advertised and attendance was initially low, although later in the day dozens of families and children came to enjoy the activities.

However speakers at the anti-EDL rally criticised the event, including Walthamstow vicar Stephen Saxby, who described it as a "farce". He said: "There are table tennis tables there - how is that celebrating the multiculturalism of this borough?" Rev Saxby also criticised the ban on all marches in the borough, calling it a "disgraceful attack on local democracy".

His views were echoed by other speakers such as Jo Cardwell of WAWF. She told the crowd: "The only reason why they [the police] applied for a ban today is not because they suddenly realised that the EDL is fascist, but because they knew there would be at least 7,000 people on the streets of Walthamstow against the EDL."

She added: "Walthamstow has broken the back of the EDL. We've built the coffin that they've climbed into".

Waltham Forest Guardian, 27 October 2012



View the Original article

Protestors outnumber attendees at Wilders lecture in Malmö

on

Anti-racists demonstrate against Wilders in MalmöWhile protesters outnumbered those attending a speech by controversial Dutch politician Geert Wilders in Malmö in southern Sweden on Saturday, the event passed off without incident.

"Our intelligence told us that we should be prepared for trouble," a Malmö police officer told The Local. But at the end of the event a colleague assured The Local that the day "had passed without incident with just minor disturbances".

The frequent critic of Islam was a guest of the anti-Islam Swedish "Freedom of the Press Society" (Tryckfrihetssällskapet) and addressed an audience of approximately 100 people at a venue in Malmö's western harbour. Outside a crowd of around 300 gathered to protest at the presence of the leader of the Dutch Party for Freedom.

The society's president Ingrid Carlqvist explained the poor turnout in that the society had received many bogus applications for tickets. In a heated confrontation, Carlqvist denounced the protesters as "screaming hordes of monkeys" whom she said had revealed her home address, claiming that she had been forced to stay in a Copenhagen hotel as a precaution.

Wilders' arrival in Malmö was shrouded in secrecy with the location of his speech only revealed on Friday afternoon due to security concerns. A heavy police presence surrounded the Kockums Fritid centre with officers confirming to The Local that the deployment was similar to that used for dealing with football hooliganism.

Protesters from Stockholm as well as Copenhagen chanting "no to racism and fascism" were joined by a large group of Scandinavian media. While police confirmed that the demonstrators generally behaved in an orderly manner, several attendees, including some journalists, were pelted with eggs and oranges as they entered the venue.

Carlqvist welcomed Wilders on stage, describing as "one of the bravest freedom fighters in the world" and the 49-year duly spoke for almost an hour. The Dutch politician told the assembled crowd that he "loved Sweden and its people" and added that "Malmö should not succumb to Islam".

Wilders was applauded several times during his talk in particular where he defended freedom of speech and cited Winston Churchill as his inspiration. He received largely sympathetic questions from the audience urging "Swedes to be good patriots" and that "patriotism is not fascism" before departing under armed guard.

The Local, 27 October 2012



View the Original article

التحول الاقتصادي والتحول السياسي

on Saturday, October 27, 2012

في مقال بعنوان ثمن الحرية يتحدث الكاتب الأمريكي صامويل هنتنجتون، صاحب كتاب صدام الحضارات عن تلازم أصيل بين الحرية الاقتصادية والحرية السياسية. ويؤكد أن التحول إلى الرأسمالية ونظام السوق الحر، يؤدي إلى حرية سياسية. ثم يشير إلى أن التحول الاقتصادي يحتاج إلى سنوات طويلة، كما أن نتائجه غير مستحبة بالنسبة للشعوب التي تمر بتجربة التحول، بينما يحدث التغير السياسي في يوم وليلة، بمجرد تنظيم انتخابات نزيهة، ويؤدي هذا إلى بهجة عامة. أي أن تنظيم الانتخابات أسهل وأسرع بكثير من تنظيم الأسواق.

ويرصد الكاتب ثلاثة أشكال للتحول: الأول يتزامن فيه التحول الاقتصادي والسياسي، والثاني يحدث فيه التحول السياسي ثم يليه الاقتصادي، بينما الشكل الأخير يحدث فيه التحول الاقتصادي ثم يليه التحول السياسي. وفي معرض نقاشه للأشكال الثلاثة يرى أن حدوث التحول السياسي أولا، يساعد جماعات الضغط الشعبية على الحركة وقد تؤدي حركتها إلى عرقلة التحول إلى نظام السوق إن لم تستطع منعه، لهذا هو لا يرجح هذا الشكل.

ويرى أن تزامن التحول صعب الحدوث ويحتاج إلى حكومة تحظى بتأييد شعبي، قادرة على اتخاذ قرارات سريعة للتحول نحو اقتصاد السوق الحر، ثم تعالج الآثار المترتبة على هذه القرارات فيما بعد. يبقى الشكل الثالث والأخير الذي يتم فيه التحول الاقتصادي تحت إشراف نظام قمعي، قادر على قمع أي حركات معارضة قد تعوق التحول. وثم يشير الكاتب إلى أن هذا هو الثمن الذي يجب أن تدفعه الشعوب الراغبة في الحرية.

من يدفع ثمن هذه الحرية المزعومة سوى الفقراء وحدهم. وإذا كان هنتنجتون وغيره من الكتاب يروجون لرخاء قادم بعد سنوات الحرمان، فإن الحقائق على الأرض تشير إلى عكس ذلك. فكل الدول التي مرت بتجربة التحول لاقتصاد السوق لم تعرف هذا الرخاء، إلا إذا اعتبرنا تضاعف ثروات الأغنياء في وقت قياسي رخاء. فلقد انتهى مفهوم دولة الرفاه الاجتماعي في الغرب منذ نهاية السبعينات، وتصاعدت سطوة سياسات اللبيرالية الجديدة أثناء وبعد انهيار الاتحاد السوفيتي، وقبل أن تبدأ عمليات التحول نحو سياسات السوق. ويمكن أن نرصد نتائج هذه السياسات في الدول التي بدأت التحول الاقتصادي، تجلت في ارتفاع الأسعار وزيادة أعداد العاطلين وتعاظم نسبة الفقر والتراجع في الخدمات الأساسية كالصحة والتعليم بسبب تخلي الدولة عن دورها الاجتماعي. أضف إلى ذلك الأزمات العالمية، التي تلقي بظلالها على فقراء العالم، كأزمة الطاقة والغذاء.

وهذا المقال ينطوي على مغالطة خطيرة، إذ يشير هنتنجتون، وغيره من الكتاب والمفكرين، إلى تلازم بنائي بين الرأسمالية والديمقراطية، وهو تلازم تهدمه نظرة واحدة لخريطة العالم وإحصاء عدد الدول الرأسمالية التي تحكمها أنظمة ديكتاتورية. بالإضافة إلى نماذج تاريخية واضحة مثل ألمانيا النازية وإيطاليا الفاشية، كما أن هناك العديد من الدول التي أنجزت التحول الاقتصادي، أو على وشك إنجازه دون أي تقدم سياسي واضح.

الأخطر والأهم أن الديمقراطية الموعودة على النمط الغربي تشبه إلى حد كبير ديمقراطية البولس اليونانية القديمة التي كانت تستبعد الفقراء والنساء والعبيد وبعدها يحكم بقية السكان المدينة بالتناوب. وهو ما نراه من سيطرة الشركات ومجموعات المصالح على الحكم في دول الغرب كافة، حيث تبقى حرية الحركة والتعبير متاحة في ما لا يتعارض مع مصالح الشركات. فحكومات الغرب تدعم أنظمة قمعية، وتدعم انقلابات عسكرية وتتدخل عسكريا حسب مصالحها والأمثلة كثيرة والتغاضي عنها من قبل المدافعين عن الغرب هو تزييف للحقائق. كما أنها لا تخدم شعوب الغرب بل تخدم مصالح الشركات المتحكمة في هذه الحكومات، فالمظاهرات الحاشدة في الغرب ضد الحرب على العراق، رغم المعلومات الكاذبة عن خطر العراق على العالم لامتلاكه أسلحة نووية، لتعتبر دليلا واضحا على تحرك حكومات الغرب ضد إرادة شعوبها. كما أن للديمقراطية الغربية أنياب، ظهرت في قمع متظاهري سياتل ومعتقلات جونتانامو وأبو غريب، وقبلها لجنة مكارثي، وما خفي أعظم.



View the
Original article

Othman Ibn Affan (18)

on

Othman Ibn Affan

Abullah Ebn Sabaa a mené le Fitna qui a eu lieu contre Othman Ibn Affan et il a réussi à étendre des rumeurs sur Sayedna Othman à travers le monde Musulman. Il a visé à le tuer et faire du monde Musulman, un monde sans leader, parce que c’était ce que les Romains ont voulu.

Une autre rumeur qui a été propagée sur Othman Ibn Affan est qu’il a continué à battre Ammar Ebn Yasser à mort, mais la vérité est que cet Ammar Ebn Yasser était en conflit avec Otba Ebn Abu Lahab, donc Sayedna Othman a voulu battre les deux légèrement et ceci n’a pas causé de haine entre n’importe lequel d’entre eux et Sayedna Othman. Othman Ibn Affan savait que cette rumeur se propage en Égypte, alors il a envoyé Ammar Ebn Yasser lui-même à la région pour dire aux gens la vérité, mais peut-être que c’était trop tard. 

Othman Ibn Affan

Il est important de mentionner que les rebelles se sont rassemblés pour couper l’adduction d’eau vers la maison d’Othman ; alors Ammar Ebn Yasser est sorti et a dit aux gens “Othman Ibn Affan a acheté le puis de Roma pour les Musulmans pour leur apporter de l’eau et maintenant l’on coupe l’eau de sa maison. Ceci n’est pas acceptable.” Et ensuite il a pris un baril d’eau pour Othman Ibn Affan pour boire.

Une autre rumeur sur Othman Ibn Affan battant le compagnon Abullah Ebn Massud jusqu’à lui causer des déchirures circulait, mais ceci n’était pas aussi vrai. La vérité est Abdullah Ebn Massud avait son propre Mushaf (le livre Saint du Coran) et quand Othman a copié le Mushaf d’Al Sayeda Hafsa il ordonna de brûler les autres copies du Mushaf parce que certains d’entre eux contenaient des erreurs. Abullah Ebn Massud n’a pas voulu que son Mushaf ait été brûlé, mais quand il apprit la raison il a dit “j’obéis peu importe ce que Othman Ibn Affan dit et même s’il m’a demandé de venir à lui en rampant, je le ferai pour lui”.

Il y a encore plus de rumeurs et les actions à prendre doivent être discutées, mais je veux m’arrêter à ce point et dire quelque chose d’important. Othman Ibn Affan prenait des décisions pour protéger la communauté Musulmane, mais les rebelles et Abullah Ebn Sabaa travaillaient pour expliquer de telles décisions comme ils étaient tous contre les Musulmans, pour qu’ils puissent mettre les gens en colère et demander vengeance. Ceci était le facteur principal qu’Abullah Ebn Sabaa a compté pour tuer le leader du monde Musulman Othman Ibn Affan.

You can also view this article in English Here



View the
Original article

Drunken thug fined for abusing police at Sunderland anti-mosque protest

on

A man arrested in connection with an EDL protest against a newly-approved mosque has been fined after he admitted swearing at riot police.

Gary Donaldson, 32, had been drinking at the Chesters Pub in Chester Road in Sunderland, when he was confronted by officers with video cameras.

Sunderland Magistrates' Court heard how Donaldson screamed expletives into the camera and became aggressive towards the officer holding the device. He was one of 13 people arrested during the protest on October 6, 2012.

Representing himself at the short hearing, Donaldson, of Frederick Street, Seaham, pleaded guilty to drunk and disorderly on Friday October 26. He was fined £35, and ordered to pay a £20 victim surcharge as well as £85 costs.

Around 200 people were involved in the demonstration on St Mark's Road, which saw members of far-right groups including the English Defence League and National Front clashing with anti-fascists and members of the Muslim community.

Scores of police armed with batons were called in as the disorder escalated, and a firecracker in a glass bottle was seen being thrown at officers.

Eight men arrested on suspicion of public order offences and another three arrested on suspicion of affray are on bail pending further enquires.

Sky Tyne and Wear, 27 October 2012



View the Original article

A Glimpse at the Political Philosophy of Islam

on

If we want to make a balanced comparison between Islamic and other views in the field of polity and form of government we should make a review of the important issues in the philosophy of politics, and on every issue find out what is the view of Islam, comparing it with the other views. We must make a detailed investigation of the basic differences between them. Very briefly, we will now mention some issues and explain the views of Islam pertaining to them in order that it may be possible to make a comparison.

The first issue is the importance of social life. Islam, like the other schools of thought, emphasizes social life. But more than this it considers it a duty to attend to social problems and to struggle for the benefit of all human beings. Being indifferent to such problems is considered in Islam to be a grave sin. This attention is so important that it sometimes becomes necessary to spend all of one’s property and even to endanger one’s own life to save others from worldly and other-worldly afflictions and harms, from going astray and from spiritual corruption, and from misfortune in the next life. It is unlikely that any school of thought other than Islam has advanced this idea so far. Of course, we believe that none of the heavenly religions have any disagreement on basic principles and rules. Naturally, they hold this view in common with Islam.

The second issue is the necessity of law for social life, since no society can survive without rules and social regulations, for otherwise it would soon succumb to chaos, deterioration and destruction. The view of Islam on this matter is also clear and does not Stand in need of an explanation. We should however, mention two points. The first point is that from the perspective of Islam, the goal of law is not only to bring about social order and discipline, but beyond this to maintain social justice; because, firstly, without justice the order would not be durable and the masses of the people would not tolerate injustice and oppression for ever; and secondly, in a society not governed by justice most people would not have the opportunity for desired growth and development and hence, the goal of man’s creation and social life would not be realized.

Another point is that, from the Islamic viewpoint, social laws should be such as to prepare the ground and context for the spiritual growth and eternal felicity of the people. At the very least they should not be inconsistent with spiritual development, for, in the view of Islam, the life of this world is but a passing phase of the entire human life which despite its short duration, has a fundamental role in human destiny. That is, it is in this phase that with his conscious behaviour the human being should prepare for himself his everlasting felicity or wretchedness. Even if a law could maintain the social order in this world but would cause eternal misfortune for humans, from this Islamic view it would not be a desirable law, even if it were to be accepted by the majority.

The third issue is how and by whom the law should be legislated. The accepted theory in most current societies is that the laws should be legislated and approved by the people themselves or their representatives. Since the consensus of all the people or of their representatives is practically impossible, the view of the majority (even if merely half plus one) is the criteria for the validity of the law.

This theory, first of all, is based on the idea that the goal of law is to satisfy the people’s needs, not to provide that which would truly benefit them. Secondly, since it is impossible to have unanimous agreement, we should suffice with the opinion of the majority. However, the first idea mentioned is not accepted by Islam, for many people wish to satisfy their bestial instincts and temporary lusts without thinking of their disastrous consequences.

Usually the number of such people is at least one half plus one, so the social laws would be dictated by the desires of such people.

It is obvious that the schools which believe in a goal beyond animal lust and base desire will not be able to condone this idea.

With regard to the second idea, that is, the validity of the vote of the majority in the absence of unanimity, it should be said that only in absence of a deciding divine and intellectual criterion can the majority be the criterion for preferring an opinion. However, in the Islamic system there do exist such divine and intellectual criteria. In addition, usually a powerful minority, by using the facilities for widespread propaganda, has an important role in channelling the thoughts and beliefs of others, and in fact what is approved is only the desire of a limited but powerful minority, not the true desire of the majority or of all the people. Furthermore, if the criterion is that the people’s choice would be valid for themselves, why shouldn’t we also accept the choice of a minority as valid for itself, even if it would result in a type of autonomy? In this case, what would be the logical justification for governments to oppose the wishes of some social groups which they rule by force?!

From the perspective of Islam with regard to this problem, laws should be legislated in such a way that they procure the benefits of the members of the society, particularly of those who desire to improve themselves and to gain eternal felicity. It is obvious that such law should be legislated by one who has enough knowledge about the real and eternal benefits of humans, and, secondly, who does not sacrifice the benefits of others for his personal interests and vain desires. It is obvious that there is no one wiser than Almighty God, Who has no need of His servants or their works, and Who has provided divine legislation only for the sake of benefitting them. Certainly, the social laws described in the heavenly revealed books do not explicitly state all the social rules which are necessary for every time and place, but religious law does provide a general framework for the derivation of regulations necessary for changing conditions of time and place, and, at least by observing the limits delineated by this framework it may be possible to avoid falling into the deadly valley of eternal perdition.

The fourth issue is that of who should enforce social law.

Islam, like most other political schools, requires the existence of a State as a power which is able to prevent violations of the law, and the lack of the State is equivalent to the suspension of law, chaos, and the violation of the rights of the weak.

It is obvious that there are two fundamental qualifications for administrators of the law, particularly for the one at the top of the pyramid of power: first, sufficient knowledge of the law in order to prevent infringement of it due to ignorance; and second, self-control over his desires in order to prevent the intentional misapplication of the law. Other qualifications, like administrative acumen, courage, and so on, can be considered as supplementary requirements. Naturally, the ideal is that the administrator of the law should generally be without ignorance, selfishness, and other vices, and such a person is one who, in religious terminology, is called ma’sum (infallible). All Muslims believe in the infallibility of the Prophet, may the peace and blessings of Allah be upon him and upon his progeny, and the Shi’ites also believe in the infallibility of the Imams, peace be upon them. In the absence of an infallible one, these criteria should be observed, to the extent possible, for the selection of the leader as well as for lower positions in the official hierarchy in a proportionate manner.

Basically, the basis of the thesis of Wiláyat-e faqih (lit., guardianship of the jurisprudent meeting all the requisite requirements) is the proposition that a person who is nearer to the station of infallibility should occupy the position of the infallible one, i.e. on top of the pyramid of power, in order that this position may be occupied by one with the best knowledge of the precepts and laws and their fundamental bases, one who has the most piety and self-control. By means of these two basic qualifications (jurisprudence and piety) it is at least possible that he will be less likely intentionally or unintentionally to transgress against the law of Islam.

Another point which may be raised here is that from an Islamic perspective no human has any intrinsic right to rule over another, even if he issues valid and just decrees, for all people, like other creatures, have been created and are the property of Almighty God, and no one may interfere with another’s property without his permission. A human being has no right even to use his own bodily parts in a manner contrary to God’s will and consequently he cannot allow others to do so. Hence, the only one Who Himself has an absolute right to govern and to depose of anyone and anything is Almighty God. Every authority and wiláyah should be from Him or at least with His sanction. It is obvious that Almighty God would never permit anyone to execute the law without having the necessary knowledge of His laws, or without there being a guarantee of the correctness of his deeds and obedience to the divine laws, or without piety and the necessary moral qualifications.

On the other hand, we know that except for the prophets and their selected successors, no one else was specifically designated by Almighty God to execute the law and to govern. So, people must try to find persons who resemble the prophets and the Ma’súmún (infallible ones) as closely as possible. It seems that the best way is first to select committed experts of religion (pious jurists), and then to allow them to select from among themselves the best one, for the experts may more correctly identify the best.

Such selection is safer from defects of an intentional or unintentional character.

It also has become clear that the political features of Islam derive from the basic elements of the world view of Islam and its view of man. That is, the emphasis on the just character of law and its harmony with human spiritual development derives from the view that God Almighty created all mankind in order that people may follow the way of development toward nearness to . God and eternal felicity by their meritorious conduct in life. The right of all humans to happiness and the enjoyment of the blessings of this world exists in order that all may advance on the way of their development in a better and speedier manner. The legislation of the divine laws and religious principles, whether they apply to the individual or society, is for determining the basic outlines of this path. The conditions of expertise in law and piety, in addition to other necessary administrative qualifications, is for securing the necessary conditions for the general development of the people, for reaching eternal felicity and for preventing intentional and unintentional deviation from the correct way of social life.

About the author



View the Original article

?مريم عليها السلام لماذا لم يذكر القرآن أهل الكهف وذكر

on

لماذا لم يذكر القرآن أهل الكهف وذكر

يسأل البعض

من هم أصحاب الكهف وغيرهم من شخصيات غير مـُعرفة في القرآن ؟

نجد أعداء الإسلام يشككوا في القرآن لأنه لم يذكر شخصيات مثل أهل الكهف وغيرهم ،
فمن هم ؟ ومتى وأين ؟

الرد :

لتعلم أن :

* لو جاءت واحدة من هؤلاء لفسدت القصة ، لأنه لو حددنا زمانها سيأتي واحد يقول : مثل ذلك الزمان الذي حدثت فيه القصة كان يسمح بها .

* ولو حددنا المكان سيقول آخر : إن المكان كان يسمح بهذه المسألة .

* ولو حددنا الأشخاص بأسمائهم فلان وفلان … فسيقول ثالث : إن مثل هذه الشخصيات يمكن أن يصدر منها مثل هذا السلوك … وإننا لسنا بقوة إيمان هؤلاء .

والحق سبحانه لم يحدد الزمان والمكان والأشخاص وجاء بها مبهمة ليدل على أن أي فتية في أي زمان وفي أي مكان يقولون ما يقولون ، ولو شخصها في واحد لفسد المراد .

لننظر إلى دقة الحق حين ضرب مثلاً للذين كفروا بامرأة نوح وامرأة لوط حين قال جل وعلا :

التَّحْرِيم
آية رقم : 10
قرآن كريم
ضَرَبَ اللَّهُ مَثَلا لِلَّذِينَ كَفَرُوا امْرَأةَ نُوحٍ وَامْرَأةَ لُوطٍ كَانَتا تَحْتَ عَبْدَينِ مِن عِبَادِنَا صَالِحَينِ فَخَانَتَاهُمْا فَلَمْ يُغْنِيَا عَنْهُمْا مِن اللَّهِ شَيْئًا وَقِيلَ ادْخُلا النَّارَ مَع الدَّاخِلِينَ

ولم يحدد لنا اسم امرأة من هاتين المرأتين ، بل ذكر الأمر المهم فقط ، وهو أن كلاً منهما زوجة لرسول كريم ، ولكن كلاً منها أصرت على الكفر فدخلتا النار .

ولكن الحق سبحانه وتعالى حين أرد التخصيص بحادث لن يتكرر في أي زمان أو مكان جاء بذكر السيدة مريم بالتشخيص والتحديد الواضح حين قال :

التحريم
آية رقم : 12
قرآن كريم
وَمَرْيَمَ ابْنَةَ عِمْرَانَ الَّتِي أَحْصَنَتْ فَرْجَهَا فَنَفَخْنَا فِيهِ مِن رُّوحِنَا وَصَدَّقَتْ بِكَلِمَاتِ رَبِّهَا وَكُتُبِهِ وَكَانَتْ مِنَ القَانِتِينَ

تحديد الحق لمريم بالاسم والحادث لماذا؟ لأن الواقعة غير قابلة للتكرار من أيَّةِ امرأة أخرى .
التشخيص هنا واجب ، لأنه لن تلد امرأة من غير زوج إلا هذه ، إنما إذا كانت المسألة ستتكرر في أي زمان أو مكان فهو سبحانه يأتي بوصفها العام ، ومثال ذلك قول الحق : {{ ألم تر إلى الذي حاج إبراهيم في ربه }} فلم يقل لنا : من هو ؟

About the author



View the Original article

The Stereotypical Questions Revisited

on

*Editor’s Note: Yesterday Muslim Academy reached a huge milestone by having 3,500 people in one day.  We asked Ehab to write a note to commemorate this special occasion, as it was his articles that helped kick-start our debates to begin with.  A Christian Egyptian writing in English, Ehab was able to show a different side of the world to the West with humor, insight, and panache.  People like Ehab are why this school work – those who trancend national and religious boundaries in an attempt to come together.  We appreciate his help and look forward to many more conversations to come.

Six months ago when I started my journey with Muslim Academy, I started with it my article that was entitled “The Stereotypical Questions i Always Get”. It talked about the questions I got over the internet for being Egyptian and a middle eastern. This was my first article here then i started to get to know the people, from the Arab world and the Western World. This helped me have a better view of the west. So after 6 months, I decided to revisit the subject but the other way around, I’d state the stereotypical questions that western people get from the Arab world in the same way.

Q: He is an American, he must be supporting Israel and the foreign policy of the United States!!

A: Not true, I have met a lot of Americans who do not like what Israel is doing and they are in fact against the foreign policy of the United States. Does that mean they hate America? No, they do not appreciate or agree with the policy of their country.

Q: A Muslim in the United States must be suffering from all kinds of torture and abuse!

A: Contrary to public belief, Muslims are not tortured in the U.S.A. Yes people started to feel differently about them following 9-11 but it’s not like what people think. Muslims are a minority, just like Christians in Egypt, do they face problems, yes they do.. Do they get killed or torture for being Muslims, no they don’t.

Q: Americans have no ethics and most of them do not believe in God.

A: No, it is only what the media conveys and the shows we see. All what we see in movies like American Pie or other movies is that the American people are sex driven and is all what they care about. There are many Americans who believe in God and refuse sex before marriage and many of them are even against drinking.

Q: American hate Arabs and Muslims.

A: Is there Americans who hate Arabs? Yes. Do all American hate Arabs, No. For instance, this website that aims to build bridges between the East and the West is made by an American who is not a Muslim. Also, do all Arabs hate Americans and want to kill them, NO.

These misconceptions and their answers show us that we should not solely depend and rely on the media and the movies to build our perception about people. Everyone should realize that misconceptions goes both ways which means that as much as you know that there are many wrong views that the West has about Arabs, you have many distorted views of the West as well.

This is why the best way is to get to know the people before you start judging them. This way, the picture you will create is a truthful and a real one.

Last of all, I would like to congratulate all of the people of Muslims Academy about the amazing success of the Website and the increasing numbers of visitors. Keep it up and good luck.

 



View the
Original article