Showing posts with label EDL's. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EDL's. Show all posts

A new insight into the EDL's support base?

on Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Last week Chatham House (the Royal Institute of International Affairs) launched a new study by Matthew Goodwin, a Nottingham University academic specialising in the far right, entitled The Roots of Extremism: The English Defence League and the Counter-Jihad Challenge. Claiming to debunk the assumptions usually made about the EDL attracting disproportionate support from the economically disadvantaged and the unemployed, Goodwin's paper produced headlines such as "Managers and skilled workers make up bulk of far right supporters" (Daily Telegraph) and "English Defence League supporters are mostly full-time workers, survey finds" (Huffington Post).

Goodwin's is the second study to attempt an analysis of the social composition and ideology of the EDL's support base. In November 2011 Demos published a report entitled Inside the EDL: Populist Politics in a Digital Age, the authors of which, Jamie Bartlett and Mark Littler, had the novel idea of placing advertisements on Facebook asking for EDL supporters to complete a survey.

This approach had some obvious weaknesses, not least the fact that an online poll necessarily skewed the results with regard to the income and educational qualifications of respondents, as internet access is closely linked to both (an OxIS study last year found that 45% of people earning £12,500 a year or less, and 61% of people with no educational qualifications, had never used the internet). However, the Demos approach did have the merit of providing a large pool of respondents. Altogether 1,295 supporters and sympathisers of the EDL participated in the Demos survey.

How does the Chatham House study improve on this? To be blunt, it doesn't. Goodwin's paper is based on an online poll by YouGov and is therefore subject to the same problems regarding internet access as the Demos survey. Moreover, unlike the authors of the Demos study, Goodwin has attempted to analyse the EDL's support base through the results of a conventional opinion poll. Given that the EDL is backed by a tiny percentage of the population (attendance at EDL demonstrations these days doesn't even reach four figures and at the time of writing its Facebook page has attracted a mere 17,205 "likes" – out of a total UK population of 63 million) it should have been obvious that the YouGov survey was going to identify very few EDL supporters.

And so it proved. YouGov polled 1,666 individuals, of whom a mere 33 stated that they agreed with the "values and methods" of the EDL. You can read YouGov's own comparison of the attitudes of EDL sympathisers and those of non-EDL respondents here. Not unexpectedly, the figures show that EDL sympathisers are obsessed with the issue of immigration and disinclined to agree with the view that the EDL are racist. But a sample of 33 respondents (39 after weighting) is obviously an inadequate statistical basis on which to draw any firm conclusions about the nature of support for the EDL.

Goodwin, however, claims that the YouGov poll uncovered 298 people whom he characterises as "supporters" and "sympathisers" of the EDL, and he bases his analysis on this much larger sample. How did Goodwin come up with such an astonishingly high figure? The answer is that he has included those respondents who said they agreed "with the values of the English Defence League but not their methods" (emphasis added). Given the widespread hostility to Islam among the non-Muslim population of the UK (and the YouGov poll provides some revealing statistics on that), it is hardly surprising that a large number of respondents should say that they share the values of a high profile Islamophobic organisation like the EDL. But to describe people who say they disagree with the EDL's methods as supporters and sympathisers is misleading if not downright fraudulent.

The differences between Goodwin's findings and those in the earlier Demos study are considerable. Demos found that 28% of respondents were unemployed, compared with the national average of 6%, and that 34% voted for the British National Party. Goodwin's study, by contrast, asserts that EDL supporters, with an unemployment rate of just 3%, "are no more likely than average to be unemployed", while a mere 1% of them back the BNP. These sharply divergent statistics are obviously to be explained by the fact that all of the individuals polled in the Demos survey were actual supporters of the EDL, whereas the large majority of those on whom Goodwin's analysis is based are not.

The Chatham House study is therefore largely useless as a means of understanding the support base of the EDL. It is an analysis, not of the EDL and its supporters, but of a much wider section of the public who share some of the EDL's views while repudiating its methods. The most you could say is that it provides an insight into the social and ideological character of potential recruits to the EDL. But that is not the way the results of the Chatham House study have been presented to, and reported by, the media.

Goodwin has a good section towards the end of his paper about the wider Islamophobic culture in which so-called "counter-jihad" organisations can take root and thrive. He points to the positive evidence that people in the 18-24 age group are much more comfortable with the multicultural society in which they have grown up and far less hostile to the Muslim community than older people are. He argues that these attitudes should be supported and encouraged, while at the same time exposing the myths and propaganda on which anti-Muslim bigotry is based. Nobody could disagree with that.

However, as Goodwin points out in the introduction to his paper, the specific challenge posed by the EDL is that it provides a focus and inspiration not just for bigots but for violent extremists. Indeed, he quotes a 2012 Europol report which emphasises that "the threat of violent right-wing extremism has reached new levels in Europe and should not be underestimated". One important means of countering this threat is to put pressure on the authorities to recognise that the EDL is a violent racist organisation of the far right – which the police generally, and the National Domestic Extremism Unit in particular, have been very reluctant to do.

To publish a study of individuals most of whom have no connection whatsoever to the EDL, and pass it off as an analysis of EDL supporters, is not a helpful contribution to achieving this objective. On the contrary, by reinforcing the view that EDL is made up of ordinary, respectable members of society – the bulk of them "managers and skilled workers", no less – Goodwin's Chatham House study and the media coverage it prompted make it less likely that the authorities will take the necessary steps to control the violent, racist, lumpen thugs who comprise the EDL's direct action wing.



View the Original article

EDL's Thanet division leader convicted of assault

on Tuesday, January 8, 2013

Hope Not Hate reports that the leader of the English Defence League's Thanet division, Gary Milsom, has been fined £150 and sentenced to 120 hours community service after being found guilty of common assault and resisting a police officer.

Milsom, operating under the witty pseudonym "Pat Riot", organised the harassment of worshippers at a mosque in his home town of Margate last September. At the time, Milsom assured the Isle of Thanet Gazette that the EDL was not racist and was committed to peaceful action.

The fraudulent character of Milsom's claim to oppose racism was exposed by a Gazette reporter who attended an EDL meeting in Margate at which "dirty Pakis" were denounced along with "dirty Muslims". Milsom's recent conviction now also demolishes his supposed commitment to non-violence.



View the Original article

EDL's planned march in Slough condemned

on Friday, December 14, 2012

Far-right group the English Defence League (EDL) is planning a demonstration in Slough early in the New Year. A website, aiming to expose and counter the EDL, says the group is planning four marches – in Slough, Cambridge, Manchester and Newcastle. The anonymous website founder claims the information was leaked to him by an EDL member.

News of the group's plans have been met with condemnation across the community. Mohammed Ayub, former president of the Pakistan Welfare Association and chaplain for Muslims at Wexham Park Hospital, Slough, believes any extremist or racist group should be banned from having a public platform.

He said: "The EDL is based on hatred and the spreading of hate, Muslim-bashing and Asian-bashing. Any organisation with this kind of message is not an organisation as far as I'm concerned." He added: "There used to be terrible racial problems in Slough and because of tireless work and dialogue between all sides of the community, they no longer exist."

James Farmer, former chairman of the Manor Park Community Forum, wants the EDL banned from Slough and said: "Wherever they march, there is always trouble."

Wayne Strutton, Conservative deputy leader for Slough Borough Council, wants more power to stop groups like the EDL holding large demonstrations.

He said: "I'm disappointed that we're getting a extremist organisation march in Slough. However, we have to respect people's freedom of expression and I hope they make their protest peacefully. If they break the law, the police will arrest them."

He added: "I wish they weren't coming to Slough, but until we have more power to stop these people, we have to respect their rights."

Slough Observer, 11 December 2012



View the Original article

Anti-fascists planning rally to counter EDL's Rotherham demo

on Friday, October 5, 2012

Anti-fascist protesters have called for a peaceful multi-cultural rally on the day the extreme right English Defence League descends on Rotherham.

The EDL has urged its followers to attend a demonstration in the town next Saturday after revelations about the sexual exploitation of young girls. Rotherham Unite Against Fascism has urged for people to attend a planned counter-rally in All Saints' Square as a show of strength against the EDL.

Pat Keenan, president of Rotherham Trades Council, said: "The overwhelming majority of people reject the EDL's attempt to use racism to divide our society. Their attempts to spread racist myths about sexual exploitation must be exposed and challenged. They seek to blame one community for society's problems. The EDL does nothing to protect the victims of sexual violence. Sexual predators and paedophiles exist in all communities, as do their victims."

He added: "Each time the EDL assemble, minorities and trades unionists are subjected to threats and racial and religious abuse. Recently the EDL were prevented from marching through Walthamstow in London due to a fantastic show of unity from the local community. It is essential that we show the same level of unity here. There's no place for Nazis, racists or their allies in Rotherham's multiracial, multicultural and multi-faith community."

A public meeting to discuss the issue will be held on Monday at 7pm at the Unity Centre. Speakers are expected to include Rotherham MP Denis MacShane, Unite Against Fascism's Weyman Bennett, faith leaders and other prominent figures.

Rotherham Advertiser, 4 October 2012



View the Original article

The EDL's 'fascist end-goal'

on Thursday, September 6, 2012

Unsurprisingly, the far right were very pleased to hear yesterday that David Cameron had succumbed to right-wing pressure and removed Sayeeda Warsi from her post as Tory party co-chairman. The subsequent news that Warsi had been appointed Faith and Communities minister was less well received.

We have already drawn attention to the English Defence League's response to Warsi's appointment (see above). However, it's also worth checking out the comments that followed this official post on the EDL's Facebook page.

(Bear in mind that at least one of the comments has been removed by the EDL admin, because as an EDL member observes "the left and all the mugs love screen shotting that shit and they use it against us". What is left presumably is the stuff that the EDL has no objection to appearing in the public domain.)

Along with personal attacks on Warsi herself, including "Fuck Islam, Fuck Warsi", "Corrupt moslem bitch!" and "TWO-FACED RAT!", there are more generalised anti-Muslim comments such as "chuck the fuckers out i hate them england is our country. fuck off back to pakistan".

The political establishment is denounced: "We have already been invaded, moslems are set to take over Western Europe without a shot being fired, due to the the appeasement of Islam by the Dhimmi cowardly politicians!"

And one comment features a threat against Cameron in particular: "I know if i ever met the wanker priminster regardless what the shit pigs would do id still smack him to the ground and make him see what he's really doing. Fucking makes me sick seeing the dirty cunts live here and live of our money!! & trying to take over what is rightfully ours!!!"

We also find calls for wider political violence. One EDL supporter predicts that "there will be a backlash soon in this country that will see 1000's killed unless things change now", while another proposes the following course of action:

"it's time to start a reveloution in this country get cameron and all the other traitors, all the islamic muslims out of britain n send em to afghan back to their smelly shitholes of a country, fuck islam forever rot you fuckers rot in your own shit n piss, i fucking hate your faith with all my heart n sole you SCUM".

A recent piece at Left Futures played down the idea of the EDL as a movement of the far right, quoting Nigel Copsey's statement (from his Faith Matters pamphlet) that "unlike the BNP (or the NF), the EDL is not driven by a fascist or neo-fascist ideological end-goal". That is true mainly in the sense that the EDL has no formal political programme and therefore lacks an official end-goal of any sort.

However, as the EDL comments on Warsi demonstrate, in practice this is a movement that indulges in rhetoric no less extreme than anything you might find on an NF or BNP website and openly promotes an identifiably fascist vision of a reborn nation purged of Muslims and the traitor politicians who appease them.



View the Original article

More fairytales from Geller about the EDL's Bristol demonstration

on Sunday, July 15, 2012

Having confidently predicted that "thousands" would be marching with the English Defence League yesterday to protest against the "Islamification of Bristol", Pamela Geller has failed to explain why only a few hundred people turned out for what was advertised as a national mobilisation by the EDL.

Shifting her ground, she has now decided to emphasise the supposedly respectable, non-violent character of the EDL, reporting that they were "well-behaved" and "maintained a calm and peaceful assembly" during their Bristol protest (in contrast to their anti-fascist opponents, who Geller claims "trashed the city and assaulted police").

However, as you can see from the above photograph (via the Press Association), it was only the weight of police numbers (officers had to be drafted in from as far away as Yorkshire to allow the deployment of a 1,000-strong riot control force) that prevented the EDL from attacking their opponents.

On their way home from the march, and without a police presence to restrain them, the EDL were free to indulge in their proclivity for drunken violence, as is illustrated by this Facebook comment (via EDL News) from a witness who was, until then, an EDL supporter (and still shares their hatred of "scummy muslims").

You can understand why Geller might want to cover up the violent nature of the EDL. She and her friend Robert Spencer are jointly launching a "worldwide counter-jihad alliance" with this gang of drunken thugs in Stockholm next month.

And we're still waiting for Geller and Spencer to explain their support for an organisation that recently carried out an attack on a peaceful anti-monarchist protest in co-operation with the neo-Nazi, white supremacist and antisemitic National Front.



View the Original article

EDL's Tommy Robinson attracts Twitter hatred after racially abusing 'underage' user

on Thursday, May 17, 2012

The leader of the far-right English Defence League has come under fire after racially abusing a girl who told him she was 15-years-old on Twitter.

Tommy Robinson, real name Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, told Twitter user 'Asianish' "You're pretty fit for a Muslim". Defending herself, she wrote back "I'm 15 and you've got the cheek to call Muslims paedos."

Robinson's Twitter abuse comes after the EDL boss highlighted the race of the Asian men convicted in Rochdale grooming case, linking their Pakistani and Afghan origins to the sexual exploitation of under-age girls.

Huffington Post, 16 May 2012

See also EDL News, 16 May 2012



View the Original article